Everyone Had a Key but Me
Chapter 2: Three Years of Waiting
1.9K words·8 min read
Protected Reading Content
I took my suitcase down from the top of the wardrobe.
Dust clung to the handle. The last time I had used it, Luca had taken me away for a long weekend after canceling two dinners in a row. He'd booked a beautiful hotel overlooking the sea and apologized so sincerely that I'd decided not to ask why every holiday we spent together had to end somewhere neither of us knew anyone.
For the past two weeks, I'd rehearsed a sensible explanation for staying: I had a job here. Moving abroad was expensive. Starting over could wait.
None of those had been the real reason.
I'd been afraid of what leaving would mean for Luca and me.
Now I packed the notebooks from my master's degree, my laptop, and the clothes I would need for work. The research I'd once been so proud of had spent long enough gathering dust while I arranged my evenings around his schedule.
I found an old notebook beneath a stack of winter scarves. On its first page, in blue ink, I'd written a question about why people continued making costly choices after discovering those choices no longer benefited them.
I had studied that exact pattern in other people's decisions.
I sat on the edge of the bed and almost laughed. Apparently, knowing the theory did not make me immune to it.
My phone lit up beside the suitcase.
Isabella had posted a screenshot of my breakup message.
"Enough with the drama. It's getting embarrassing. 🙄"
The comments were already piling up.
"Another breakup threat. Terrifying."
"She's an office assistant. What exactly does she think she's bringing to the table?"
"Luca could have anyone. She should be grateful he even looks at her."
I read them once.
There were familiar names among the comments. People who had eaten dinner with us, accepted my help with arrangements, and greeted me pleasantly whenever Luca brought me to an event. Their confidence in judging my relationship was astonishing, considering how little any of them had bothered to ask me about my life.
For a moment, I wanted to type a long defense. I wanted to explain my education, my research, the job offer waiting in Copenhagen, and everything I had done for myself before I ever met Luca.
Then I realized how absurd that would be. I was twenty-something years old, packing for an international research position, and considering presenting my qualifications to strangers who had decided I was unworthy of my own boyfriend.
I left a comment of my own.
"It wasn't a threat. You're welcome to stop discussing me now."
I set the phone down and continued folding clothes. A few seconds later, it rang.
Luca called almost immediately.
"I've told her to take it down."
"Good."
"They were being idiots, Elena. None of them knows anything about your work. I'll deal with them." His voice softened. "You know I don't think that about you."
I folded a sweater and put it in the suitcase.
"Elena?"
"I'm here."
"Then talk to me."
There was nothing left I wanted to explain. I had spent three years trying to find words he would take seriously. I wasn't going to spend my last night at home doing it again.
He mistook the silence for surrender.
"It's almost midnight. Get some sleep. Tomorrow's our anniversary. I'll take you to Bellini's."
"Luca—"
"If you mean what you said, tell me to my face." His voice tightened. "Three years deserves more than a text."
Three years did deserve more than a text. They deserved honesty. They deserved an acknowledgment that we had loved each other, made mistakes, and reached a place where I could no longer stay.
But Luca spoke as though the length of our relationship gave him the right to refuse its ending.
I looked at the small, empty jewelry box on my dresser.
My mother's bracelet was still with him. The clasp had broken, and he'd offered to have his jeweler repair it. I'd asked twice whether it was ready. Both times, he'd said not yet.
The bracelet was made of delicate silver links surrounding a tiny oval portrait beneath glass. My grandmother had told me that my father gave it to my mother before I was born. When I was little, I used to sit on her lap and turn the oval back and forth, fascinated by the miniature painting.
After she died, my grandmother kept it in a velvet pouch until I was old enough to wear it without fear of losing it. It was one of the few things I owned that still seemed to carry the warmth of my mother's hands.
I had trusted Luca with it because the clasp was damaged and he knew a specialist who restored antique jewelry. He had promised the repair would be done carefully.
Whatever happened between us, I could not leave the country without collecting it.
"All right," I said. "One conversation. And bring my bracelet."
"I will."
His relief was immediate. He began talking about the restaurant, about a table he would arrange, about how we could put the last twenty-four hours behind us.
I let him finish without correcting him. My decision had not changed.
After the call, I sent the research coordinator the documents she requested. She confirmed that the team could arrange temporary accommodation and transportation from the airport. I checked my passport's expiration date, reviewed the employment paperwork, and made a list of the accounts I would need to update.
The practical tasks steadied me. Each one pointed toward a future that had existed long before Luca and could exist after him.
I slept for only a few hours. In the morning, I packed the rest of my clothes, emailed my employer about an urgent meeting, and separated the belongings I could take from those I would arrange to ship later.
My apartment looked strangely familiar and unfamiliar at once. Every object seemed to ask whether I was truly leaving.
At one the next afternoon, Luca sent me the restaurant address.
Bellini's was a little Italian place I'd mentioned a month earlier. The dining room booked weeks in advance, but they kept a few tables for walk-ins. Luca said he'd come early to put our names down.
The Don of the Moretti family could have made one call and cleared the room. Instead, he was apparently waiting like everyone else because I'd once said I hated watching people scramble to accommodate him.
It was the sort of thoughtful gesture that used to undo me. Luca remembered small preferences, even when he ignored the larger ones.
Every few minutes, another update arrived.
"Still twelve parties ahead of us."
"Down to nine."
It was brutally hot outside.
"Stay out of the sun," I wrote.
He replied with a sticker of a small gray cat giving a solemn nod.
Milo.
Luca had brought him to my apartment during our first month together.
"We can't live together," he'd said, stroking the kitten's head, "so I've found you a little bodyguard."
He'd bought the food, booked the vet appointments, and called himself Dad with a straight face.
Milo had slipped through an open door a year later. A car had hit him before I could get outside.
Afterward, I'd turned my favorite photographs into stickers because I couldn't bear to stop seeing his face.
Luca used them whenever we fought. Milo looking sorry. Milo begging forgiveness. Milo sprawled on his back in defeat.
They used to make me soften before he'd even apologized.
I touched the little gray face on the screen.
There had been love. Real tenderness, too. I didn't have to pretend otherwise to know I was finished.
I remembered Luca sitting beside me on the kitchen floor after Milo died, holding a box of tissues while I cried so hard I could barely speak. He had stayed until morning, ignoring his ringing phone, and made tea whenever my hands started shaking.
That version of him had been real.
So was the man who let Isabella occupy the place I had never been permitted to enter. So was the man who demanded that I explain my pain politely while others mocked it.
I could hold both truths without making excuses for either.
By late afternoon, the research coordinator had sent my travel itinerary. My flight would depart just after midnight, assuming I completed the final confirmation. I kept the email open on my phone as I dressed.
I chose a simple cream blouse and dark trousers. Not the dress Luca liked, not the earrings he had once said made me look like I belonged beside him. I wanted to arrive looking like myself.
At five thirty, Luca said there were ten people still waiting ahead of us. I left early so he wouldn't have to wait alone.
The journey took longer than expected. Traffic moved slowly beneath the afternoon heat, and the restaurant district was crowded with people looking for dinner. I checked the address again as I approached Bellini's.
From across the street, I saw him through the restaurant window.
He was already seated.
Isabella sat beside him, eating from a slice of cake between them.
I stopped walking.
There was a candle on the table, now extinguished. Isabella leaned toward him with the comfortable intimacy of someone who expected her presence to be welcomed. Luca said something I couldn't hear, and she laughed.
I looked at the messages on my phone. He had spent hours updating me about the waiting list. He had not mentioned that Isabella would be joining us.
Yesterday, she had humiliated me in his home. Last night, she had shared my breakup message publicly. Today, on our anniversary, she was sitting beside him at the restaurant where he had promised we would talk.
I felt the last thread of hope loosen.
Luca spotted me and came outside at once. His hand reached for mine.
I stepped out of reach.
He glanced at his empty hand, then back at me.
"I thought you coming meant we'd worked this out."
"No. I came to end it in person. And to collect my bracelet."
His jaw tightened.
"Elena, don't do this on the sidewalk."
"Then give me what belongs to me, and we won't need to discuss anything here."
He looked over his shoulder toward the restaurant. I followed his gaze. Isabella had risen from her seat and was watching us through the window.
"She's here to apologize," Luca said.
"She could have sent a message."
"You know that's not the same."
"Neither is a private anniversary dinner with an uninvited guest."
His expression closed. For a moment, I recognized the man whose employees obeyed before he finished speaking.
"We'll talk inside."
"I don't want to go inside."
He caught my sleeve and guided me toward the private dining room. When I resisted, his grip tightened.
"Luca. Let go."
He kept walking, apparently convinced that getting me away from the street would settle everything. My injured pride became something sharper and colder. I had come here voluntarily. That did not mean he was entitled to decide where I stood or when I could leave.
"Just come inside."
You May Also Like
More stories readers often continue with after this chapter.