My Birth Family Made My Twins Check Coats
Chapter 3: The Woman Who Knew My First Four Days
2.2K words·10 min read
Protected Reading Content
My husband called at ten.
I was still sitting in the car in our driveway in Westerville, staring at the garage door and trying to decide whether I felt more angry or foolish.
The twins had gone inside a few minutes earlier. Through the front window, I could see the kitchen light turn on.
Daniel's name appeared on my phone.
I answered before the second ring.
"How bad?" he asked.
Behind him, a gym full of teenagers was screaming at a robot.
I could hear the familiar sound of Daniel trying to make himself heard over excited students.
"They told everyone I'm a family friend," I said.
He was quiet for a second.
"Then don't go back if it isn't fun. I'm home tomorrow night. I took Monday off."
I closed my eyes.
Daniel had never asked me to justify why this mattered. He understood that being loved by the parents who raised me didn't erase the questions I'd carried about my birth.
He also understood that I didn't owe my biological family access to our children merely because we shared DNA.
"Your robot sounds like it's losing," I said.
"It's on fire. That's different."
Somebody yelled his name from across the gym.
"Go to bed, Claire. Love you."
"Love you too."
He hung up.
That was Daniel. Short and warm, like a hand resting against the back of my neck.
He didn't solve every problem.
He didn't offer to call Grant and explain who I was.
He simply reminded me that I could leave any place that refused to treat my family with respect.
I sat there another moment.
Then headlights swung across the garage door.
A white car pulled into the driveway behind mine.
Vivian stepped out.
She still wore the green silk dress from dinner beneath a camel coat. Her heels clicked against the pavement as she approached the house.
I looked at the clock.
10:17 p.m.
She had driven from Bexley to Westerville after a family dinner, apparently to continue a conversation that should have ended when I left.
I got out of my car.
Vivian smiled as though we were meeting for coffee.
"Claire. I'm glad you're still awake."
"What are you doing here?"
She glanced toward the house.
"I thought we should talk. Just us."
I walked up the porch steps and turned around, positioning myself between Vivian and the front door.
Through the screen, I could see two shadows near the staircase. My daughters had heard the car.
I wasn't surprised.
They'd inherited my ability to notice when something was wrong.
"Can we talk inside?" Vivian asked.
"We can talk here."
She looked briefly offended.
Then her smile returned.
"Of course. I just didn't want you standing in the cold."
I folded my arms.
"Then don't take long."
The porch light hummed above us.
Vivian pulled her coat closed.
"I was a baby too, Claire. Blaming me won't get you anything."
I stared at her.
"I haven't blamed you for anything."
"Good. Then let me give you some advice."
She spoke with the gentle authority of someone who'd spent her life believing softness made an insult harmless.
"Take the deal. Grant takes care of me. He always has. Think about your kids."
"I am thinking about my kids."
Vivian looked toward the screen door.
"They're just starting," she said. "Don't let them get a taste of this life and then get sent back where they came from. I mean that as a kindness."
I felt my face go still.
"Sent back," I repeated.
"It's easier to never know what you're missing."
There it was.
The belief beneath every smile at that dinner table.
They thought my daughters had seen chandeliers and silver serving dishes and would now spend the rest of their lives longing to return.
They thought I'd be grateful enough for a wealthy surname to overlook how they'd treated us.
They didn't understand that my daughters had grown up in a secure, loving home with opportunities we'd worked hard to provide.
They didn't know our family owned a business worth far more than the assumptions Grant had made from a thirty-dollar online report.
And they didn't know that a warm kitchen with Daniel making terrible jokes was worth more to me than every chandelier in the Whitmore dining room.
"Vivian," I said, "my children already have a life. I'm not asking your family to give them one."
She blinked.
"I'm only trying to help."
"You heard Grant call them strays today."
Her mouth tightened.
"Grant says things when he's stressed."
"You heard him."
"He didn't mean it personally."
I almost laughed.
I'd heard plenty of excuses for cruel behavior in my life.
That one was new.
Apparently, calling someone's children mutts wasn't personal if the speaker was wealthy enough.
"My daughters were standing outside the door," I said. "They heard every word."
Vivian glanced at the house again.
"Then perhaps they should learn not to listen to private conversations."
I felt something inside me turn cold.
"You came to my house to tell me my daughters are the problem?"
"That's not what I said."
"It's what you keep saying, just more politely."
For the first time, her smile vanished.
She looked toward the street, where another neighbor's porch light had come on.
"You really don't understand how this family works," she said.
"I'm beginning to."
Vivian looked at the pearls around my neck.
Her expression shifted.
"And you were lucky, in a way. A January baby, left in a place like that."
I stared at her.
"I was barely breathing."
"You weren't breathing at all. That's what she—"
Vivian stopped.
The words seemed to hang between us in the cold air.
I felt the porch boards beneath my shoes.
I heard the faint mechanical sound of our heating system starting inside.
I looked directly at her.
"She who?"
Half a second passed.
Then Vivian's face went smooth again.
"Lorraine," she said. "The woman who had me. Surely somebody told you."
Nobody had.
The lawyer who contacted me hadn't mentioned a woman named Lorraine.
Grant hadn't mentioned her during his presentation about the family trust.
My birth parents hadn't mentioned her when I asked whether anyone knew who switched the babies.
And my birth father had insisted nobody should investigate the disappearance because a scandal could damage the family's business interests.
Yet Vivian had just spoken as though she knew something about my condition when I was found.
Something more specific than the brief account I'd given that afternoon.
"Who is Lorraine?" I asked.
Vivian looked toward her car.
"I told you. The woman who had me."
"You mean your biological mother?"
"The woman who raised me before the Whitmores. It was complicated."
I studied her.
Vivian had been raised as a Whitmore. The family's explanation was that she'd come home from the hospital as their baby.
Now she was describing another woman with knowledge of the first days of our lives.
I needed to know which parts of her story were true.
But I wasn't going to let her change the subject with a vague reference and a worried glance toward the street.
"What exactly did Lorraine tell you?"
Vivian's voice hardened.
"You're making something out of nothing."
"You said I wasn't breathing at all. How would you know that?"
"People talked. It was a long time ago."
"Who talked?"
She looked annoyed.
"Claire, this is why Grant thinks you're going to cause trouble. You take one little comment and turn it into an investigation."
I thought about my first four days.
A newborn left in a restroom.
A woman whose name I'd never heard.
A family determined not to involve the police.
It didn't feel like one little comment.
"I'm asking a question about my own life," I said.
"You should be grateful you have a life to ask about."
The words landed harder than I'd expected.
Not because they frightened me.
Because they revealed how little she understood the people who had raised me.
Frank and Margaret Novak hadn't taught me to be grateful merely for surviving.
They'd taught me that survival was the beginning of a responsibility to live honestly.
I looked at Vivian.
"You don't get to say any of this to me."
Something knocked against the wall inside.
Two quick taps.
One twin telling the other to be quiet.
Vivian looked past me toward the screen door.
Her gentle smile returned immediately.
"They're sweet, really."
I didn't answer.
She descended one step, then turned back.
"Sign before Saturday. After the party, this price is gone. The trust bank wants its paperwork by December first, and Grant wants it done first."
I looked at her.
"What happens if I don't sign?"
Vivian tilted her head.
"Then you'll make things harder for everybody."
"Everybody?"
"Your children, for one. You don't want them caught in a family dispute."
I stared at her.
She'd come to my house late at night, insulted my daughters, warned me to surrender whatever rights I might have, and revealed a detail about my infancy nobody else had mentioned.
Then she'd suggested I was the one putting my children in the middle.
"My children are not bargaining chips," I said.
Vivian's smile tightened.
"I hope you'll think about what I've said."
"I will."
It was the truth.
I would think about every word.
Especially the ones she hadn't intended to say.
She walked down the steps and returned to her white car.
I watched her back out of the driveway before I opened the front door.
My daughters were standing in the hallway.
Neither pretended they hadn't been listening.
"Please tell me we're not going back there," one said.
I closed the door.
"We're not making any decisions tonight."
Her sister crossed her arms.
"She basically threatened us."
"I heard."
"And she knew something about when you were a baby."
I looked at them.
"I heard that too."
For a moment, the three of us stood in the quiet hallway.
Then I opened my arms.
They stepped into them.
At sixteen, they were nearly my height. I couldn't gather them against me the way I used to when they were little, but I held them anyway.
"You don't have to prove anything to those people," I said.
"Neither do you," one answered.
My throat tightened.
They were right.
I didn't need to reveal Bluestar or Rowan to establish my worth.
But I did need to decide whether the Whitmores were hiding information about how I became the baby in that church restroom.
And I needed to understand why Grant was in such a hurry to obtain my signature.
The twins went upstairs after I promised to call Daniel in the morning.
I returned to the kitchen, made a cup of tea, and opened my notebook.
I had used notebooks for business decisions since the day I bought my first truck.
When something didn't make sense, I wrote down what I knew before opinions started filling the gaps.
On a fresh page, I wrote the date.
Under it, I listed the facts.
DNA results questioned Vivian's parentage.
My birth mother matched me through a genealogy site.
Grant controlled his father's legal and financial correspondence under a power of attorney.
The family offered five hundred thousand dollars attached to a release concerning the trust.
My birth father opposed outside investigation.
Vivian knew the name Lorraine and appeared to know a detail about my condition when I was found.
I stared at the final line.
Then I wrote one more.
Vivian wants a signature before Saturday.
I didn't know what the deadline meant.
I didn't know whether Lorraine was alive or whether Vivian was repeating something she'd been told years earlier.
And I didn't know whether my birth family understood the actual size of the woman they were trying to buy off.
But I knew something about business agreements.
When somebody insisted you sign immediately, the first question wasn't how much they were offering.
It was what they were afraid you would discover if you waited.
I closed the notebook.
Upstairs, one of the twins laughed at something her sister said.
The sound traveled down the hallway and settled around me like a blanket.
I had spent the afternoon and evening among people who shared my blood and treated my children as though they had no place in the family.
Now I was home with the people who had never required a DNA test to know they belonged to me.
Saturday was coming.
So was the birthday party.
My niece was still desperate to book a singer named Rowan.
Grant's business partners were still counting on a Bluestar contract.
And somewhere in a folder I'd brought home, a release agreement was waiting for my signature.
I didn't intend to sign anything until I understood what it meant.
I also didn't intend to forget the name Vivian had let slip.
Lorraine.
Whatever happened forty-five years ago, someone had known more than the Whitmores were willing to tell me.
And for the first time since the lawyer's call, I had a name to start with.
You May Also Like
More stories readers often continue with after this chapter.